Compare pre-tax Traditional and after-tax Roth contributions on an equal after-tax outlay basis. Evaluate both after-tax end values, dollar difference, break-even retirement tax rate, and IRS MAGI phase-out limits.
Enter your values below to calculate the exact result and step-by-step breakdown.
With a 24% current tax rate, allocating $10,000 pre-tax to Traditional equals $7,600 after-tax contributed to Roth.
Because the expected retirement tax rate (15.0%) is lower than the current marginal tax rate (24.0%), the Traditional account retains 85.0% of terminal value vs. 76.0% for Roth.
Because multiplication is commutative, C(1 + r)ⁿ appears identically in both equations. Dividing both sides by C(1 + r)ⁿ reduces the comparison to (1 − t_ret) = 85.0% versus (1 − t_now) = 76.0%. The break-even retirement tax rate is therefore always equal to the current marginal tax rate (24.0%).
Traditional IRAs and 401(k)s require mandatory annual withdrawals starting at age 73 (increasing to age 75 in 2033 under SECURE 2.0), even if the account owner does not need the cash flow. These distributions are taxed as ordinary income and can increase taxable Social Security benefits or Medicare Part B/D IRMAA surcharges.
Roth IRAs and Designated Roth 401(k)s have no lifetime RMDs for the original owner (SECURE 2.0 removed pre-death RMDs for Roth employer plans starting in 2024), allowing balances to compound undisturbed for late-life expenses or estate planning.
Direct Roth IRA contributions are subject to Modified Adjusted Gross Income (MAGI) phase-outs ($150,000–$165,000 Single and $236,000–$246,000 Married Filing Jointly in 2025). High earners exceeding these limits cannot contribute directly to a Roth IRA without using a non-deductible Traditional IRA conversion (“Backdoor Roth”), which is subject to the IRS Pro-Rata aggregation rule.
Traditional IRA tax deductions also phase out if you or your spouse participate in a workplace retirement plan ($79,000–$89,000 Single; $126,000–$146,000 MFJ in 2025). By contrast, Roth 401(k) and Traditional 401(k) plans have no statutory income limits on employee elective deferrals.
Future tax laws, personal spending needs, and filing status (such as transitioning from Married Filing Jointly to Single filer status in widowhood) are uncertain over multi-decade horizons. Holding both Traditional and Roth balances allows retirees to manage their taxable income bracket each year.
In retirement, savers often draw from Traditional accounts to fill the standard deduction ($0% tax) and lower progressive brackets (10%–12%), then draw from Roth accounts for additional spending without pushing income into higher brackets. Additionally, direct Roth IRA contributions (principal only) can be withdrawn at any time without tax or penalty.
Source: IRS Notice 2024-80 & IRS Publication 590-A · Effective Tax Year 2025 (Updated 2025-01-10) · IRC §§ 401(k), 402(g), 408A
| Statutory Rule / Provision | Traditional Account | Roth Account | Statutory Threshold (2025) |
|---|---|---|---|
| IRA Annual Contribution Limit (Under Age 50) | Combined cap across Traditional + Roth IRAs | Combined cap across Traditional + Roth IRAs | $7,000 |
| IRA Age 50+ Catch-Up Contribution | Additional $1,000 ($8,000 total) | Additional $1,000 ($8,000 total) | +$1,000 ($8,000 total) |
| Roth IRA MAGI Phase-Out (Single / Head of Household) | No income cap on non-deductible contributions | Direct contribution phases out to $0 | $150,000 – $165,000 |
| Roth IRA MAGI Phase-Out (Married Filing Jointly) | No income cap on non-deductible contributions | Direct contribution phases out to $0 | $236,000 – $246,000 |
| Traditional IRA Deduction Phase-Out (Workplace Plan Covered) | Upfront tax deduction phases out by MAGI | N/A (Roth contributions are never deductible) | $79,000 – $89,000 (Single) · $126,000 – $146,000 (MFJ) |
| 401(k) / 403(b) / 457(b) Elective Deferral Limit | No income limit on pre-tax deferrals | No income limit on Designated Roth 401(k) | $23,500 |
| 401(k) Age 50+ / Age 60–63 SECURE 2.0 Catch-Up | Available across employer plans | Available across Designated Roth plans | +$7,500 (50+) · +$11,250 (60–63) |
When evaluating t_now versus t_ret, remember that pre-tax Traditional contributions are deducted from the top of your current income—saving tax at your current marginal rate. In retirement, if Traditional withdrawals are your primary income source, those withdrawals first fill the standard deduction (0% tax) and lower progressive tax brackets (10%, 12%) before reaching higher brackets, resulting in a lower effective tax rate on total withdrawals. Conversely, if Social Security, pensions, or required minimum distributions already fill your lower brackets in retirement, additional Traditional withdrawals will be taxed at your retirement marginal bracket. This calculator models mathematical projections for educational comparison and is not personalized tax or investment advice.
Model IRS $23,500 elective deferrals, employer match capture, and SECURE 2.0 catch-up rules.
Find your exact federal marginal tax bracket, effective tax rate, and standard deduction.
Calculate mandatory Required Minimum Distributions, SECURE 2.0 ages (73/75), and Table II/III factors.
Disclaimer: Estimate only, not financial, lending, or investment advice. Figures are mathematical projections based on your inputs and do not represent a loan offer or guaranteed return.
Compares the after-tax future value of a pre-tax contribution taxed upon withdrawal against an equivalent after-tax Roth contribution that compounds and withdraws 100% tax-free.
Comparing a $10,000 pre-tax Traditional deferral vs. $7,600 after-tax Roth deferral at 7% return for 25 years.
Applies equal after-tax cash flow methodology so both options have the exact same impact on today’s paycheck.
Future tax law changes may alter retirement tax brackets.
When modeling a 15- to 30-year financial plan, a 9% nominal stock market return looks dramatic on paper, but inflation quietly erodes what those future dollars can buy. Subtracting 2.5% to 3.0% for inflation gives you a 6.0% to 6.5% "real return," which shows your future nest egg in today's purchasing power so you can compare it directly against your current monthly living expenses.
A dollar-for-dollar or 50% employer match up to 6% of pay is an instant, risk-free 50% to 100% return before market compounding even starts.
Divide total closing costs by your monthly payment savings (e.g., $4,200 closing costs ÷ $175/mo savings = 24 months). If you plan to sell or move before month 24, refinancing loses money.
How the percentage of take-home pay you invest determines how many years it takes to build a 25× annual-expense portfolio (assuming 5% real inflation-adjusted return).
| Savings Rate (% of Net Pay) | Annual Expenses Covered | Approx. Years to 25× Expenses | Safe 4% Withdrawal Target |
|---|---|---|---|
| 10% Savings Rate | 90% spent / 10% invested | ~51 Years | Replaces 100% of spending at 25× |
| 20% Savings Rate | 80% spent / 20% invested | ~37 Years | Standard 35–40 yr career track |
| 35% Savings Rate | 65% spent / 35% invested | ~25 Years | Accelerated early-retirement track |
| 50% Savings Rate | 50% spent / 50% invested | ~17 Years | Every working year funds 1 year off |